South Florida Blade
 
Email:   Password:   login or create account
January 7, 2009

HOME > VIEWPOINT > EDITORIAL    

More from this author
PHIL LaPADULA

MORE INFO:

Phil LaPadula is the editor of the Express and can be reached at plapadula@expressgaynews.com.

Printer-friendly
Letter to the Editor

MOST VIEWED ARTICLES
Viewpoint: The Great Gay Exception
News: Year in Review
News: Cities vie for major gay sports event
Viewpoint: Bitch Session
A&E: Find the holiday spirit at Jimmie’s
News: A Year of Wins and Losses
spacer Park sex bill could destroy lives of innocent gay men
Making public sex a felony is another step toward a prison state

By PHIL LaPADULA
APR. 3, 2008
spacer

With 2.3 million people behind bars, the United States has the highest incarceration rate in the world, far ahead of communist China,Russia and Iran. Three jurisdictions in Florida — the city of Jacksonville and Polk and Pinellas counties — rank in the top 10 for highest incarceration rates in the United States, according to a recent report by the Justice Policy Institute.

But all of those caged people are apparently not enough for Florida Rep.William D. Snyder,who has proposed House Bill 801. Titled “Lewdness and Indecent Exposure,” the bill’s draconian penalties would be yet another step toward the full establishment of the Gulag America.

If Snyder’s bill is passed, anyone arrested for engaging in sexual conduct in a public park or on a public beach could face felony charges. In fact, the bill makes it a felony to engage in "unnatural or lascivious acts" with another person in or within 1,000 feet of a public park, a public beach, a community center, a child- care facility or a school. Engaging in sexual conduct in a park are on a beach is currently a misdemeanor.

The bill does not define "unnatural and lascivious," so one wonders whether two guys kissing in a park or holding hands would be considered "unnatural." The bill also makes no stipulation about children having to be present in the area of the offense in order for a felony charge to be leveled.

I have made it clear several times in this column that I think people who have sex in the bushes in public parks are engaging in tasteless and infantile behavior. Some of you may think it's a good idea to enhance penalties for such behavior to deter it. But there are many problems with this bill — as well as with the enforcement of " lewd and lascivious laws" with so-called "sting" operations — that should sound alarm bells not only in the gay community but for anyone who cares about protecting the rights of innocent people to be free from harassment and the threat of false arrest.

First of all, we have seen numerous times that it is not necessary to actually engage in any sexual behavior to fall prey to these laws and sting operations. For example, a Boca Raton priest was arrested in a park restroom in North Carolina last September for simply asking a man,who turned out to be an undercover officer, to go home with him and have sex. The priest, whom I won't name because he has been embarrassed enough,was charged with "soliciting for a crime against nature" and he lost his job.

In a more recent example that hits closer to home, Patrick Neptune, a freelance photographer, told the New Times that he was stalked and terrorized by gun-wielding Fort Lauderdale police officers on Feb. 22. According to Neptune, his "crime" was that he had decided to go to the beach in the wee hours of the morning to photograph a sunrise.He was waiting outside his car for the sun to rise when a black sports car with an undercover office spotted him and apparently assumed that he was at the beach cruising for gay sex. Neptune told the New Times that the black sports car followed him to a BP gas station,where a bearded undercover officer got out of the car and pointed a gun at him. Other officers in a marked car joined the bearded officer, and the bearded officer asked Neptune if he was out "cruising for cock," according to Neptune. He was not arrested, but Neptune has filed a complaint against the Fort Lauderdale Police Department.

And who can forget the situation at John Lloyd Park a few years ago when numerous gay men came forward and reported being harassed, cited for dubious trespassing violations and falsely arrested during a crackdown on sexual activity in the park. One gay man was charged with “indecent exposure” for wearing a white bathing suit that a park officer thought was not opaque enough.He was acquitted of the charge.

Another gay man, who had read newspaper articles about the alleged police harassment, was arrested for simply stating to an undercover officer, “Watch out. They’re arresting someone over there.” He is currently suing the state for false arrest.

There is often no surveillance tape of an incident in a remote area such as a park and no corroborating witnesses. It is often just the word of an undercover officer claiming that a park patron came on to him.

But possibly the most compelling reason to kill HB 801 is that public sex is not an increasing problem; the police data show it is, in fact, a diminishing phenomenon as more gay men seek anonymous encounters through internet chat rooms and at bathhouses.

As it was originally written, Snyder's bill would have also made it a felony to expose one's sexual organs — or to be naked — in, or within 1,000 feet, of a park, public beach, school or day- care center.But he has apparently agreed to amend the bill and remove the "indecent exposure" section after being pressured by naturist groups and others who fought to protect Haulover Beach, where nude sunbathing is permitted, from Snyder's body phobia.

I have often wondered why these rightwing people think it's a healthy thing to teach people to be ashamed of their bodies. Why is something ...

continued on next page




1  |  2


email   password
The following comments were posted by our readers and were not edited by floridablade.com.  We ask that you treat others with respect; any post deemed offensive will be removed.